Articles
Top 10 Umrah Scams to Avoid and How to Spot Them Early
Osama Naseer · 9 November 2026 · 21 min
The most damaging umrah scams are not clever: someone takes your money for a ticket, visa, hotel or return flight that was never properly arranged, and you find out at the airport or in Makkah. The ten below each come from a court ruling, a police case or an official warning. The best protection is the same in nearly every case: check the operator on an official list, pay into a company bank account, and confirm your flight and hotel yourself before the departure date.
A note on how to read this list. Some of these cases ended in conviction. Others are police investigations or the claims of people who say they lost money, and we say which is which. We name a company only where a court has convicted it. The point is the pattern, because the same tricks turn up under new names.
How umrah scams compare at a glance
| Scam | When you find out | Evidence behind it | The check that helps most |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Price too low to be real | Months later, no departure | Indonesian court verdict, 2018 | Compare with the going rate |
| 2. Endless postponements | Days before, or on departure day | Malaysian police case and complaints, 2024–25 | Ask for visa and flight proof early |
| 3. Tickets that do not exist | At the airport | Malaysian Court of Appeal, 2026 | Check the booking with the airline |
| 4. Hotel not arranged | On arrival in Saudi Arabia | Saudi ministry suspensions, 2026 | Confirm the hotel and its licence |
| 5. Return flight unpaid | In Makkah, near the end | Maldives ministry action, 2023–24 | Check the return leg separately |
| 6. Fake websites | After you pay | Saudi, Dubai and UK warnings | Type the address yourself |
| 7. WhatsApp links about Nusuk or Rawdah | During your stay | Indonesian officials, Madinah, 2026 | Never click, and never pay |
| 8. Umrah as a business reward | When the trip never comes | Malaysian complaints, 2025 | Separate the trip from the sales scheme |
| 9. Free Umrah with a job | After arrival, when it may be too late | Pakistani FIA arrests, 2025 | Treat “free” plus “work” as a red flag |
| 10. Fake Zamzam | Often never | Saudi seizures, 2017 | Buy only from authorised sellers |
1. A price too low to be real

This is the largest Umrah fraud we could document. The Indonesian operator First Travel sold a package at about Rp 14.3 million when, according to Arab News, the government’s price reference was set at no less than Rp 20 million. The Depok District Court jailed its two owners in May 2018, for 20 and 18 years, for fraud and money laundering. Arab News reported the judges’ finding that the defendants knew from the start that the price could not pay for anyone’s Umrah.
The numbers explain how it lasted. Between December 2016 and May 2017, 72,682 people signed up for the cheap package and only about 14,000 travelled. Reports put the losses at about Rp 848 billion and differ slightly on the victims: The Jakarta Post says 56,682 and Arab News says 58,682. The Jakarta Post’s editorial board described agencies undercutting the market to win volume, then placing deposits in unregistered companies that promised unreasonable returns and later disappeared. In 2019 The Jakarta Post reported victims were still unsure about compensation, after the Supreme Court ruled that the company’s assets were subject to state confiscation.
How to spot it early: get quotes from three operators for the same dates, hotels and flights. If one is far lower, ask what is missing. “Other pilgrims have already gone” proves little, since about 14,000 people did travel with First Travel. A long gap between paying and flying is a warning sign too. After this case, Indonesia required that customers reach Makkah within six months of their first payment.
2. The agency that keeps postponing

In January 2025, Malaysian police arrested a married couple who owned a travel agency in Sepang, after more than 300 pilgrims were not flown to Saudi Arabia. Selangor’s police chief put the count at 379 victims and the estimated losses at RM2.1 million. One complainant said she lost RM11,000. The chief said there were “clear indications of fraud” in the way visa applications and flight bookings had been handled. Those were police statements during an investigation. We have not confirmed the outcome.
Two details are worth remembering. The agency advertised on TikTok and recruited through appointed agents, so many customers may never have dealt with the company directly. And The Sun reported the agency was licensed. A licence is the first check, not the last one.
A smaller complaint from Melaka shows how the delay works. In 2024, 21 people said they had lost over RM135,000 to a company one of them had already travelled with. By their account it took instalments, issued an offer letter, ran two Umrah courses, then announced two days before departure that the flight had moved because it was full. A second postponement followed, with the admission that bookings had failed. They filed a police report and went to the Consumer Claims Tribunal.
How to spot it early: classes and offer letters are not evidence of a booking. About three weeks before you fly, ask for your visa copy and airline booking reference. A change of date with no written reason is your signal to ask for a refund in writing.
3. Tickets and itineraries that do not exist

This one has been tested all the way up to an appeal court. On 2 September 2026, Malaysia’s Court of Appeal upheld the conviction of a former managing director on 23 counts of cheating, while cutting his sentence from 10 years to five. He had collected RM434,250 from 202 people for an Umrah group and Egypt trip, without telling them the company had been wound up by a court about a year earlier. Payments went into his own, his wife’s and employees’ accounts. The participants received itineraries and tickets for late January 2016, and at Kuala Lumpur International Airport they learned those did not exist.
Pakistan has recent reports of the same pattern. Dawn reported in February 2026 that two travel agents were arrested in Dinga, Gujrat district, for allegedly taking Rs200,000 to Rs300,000 each from 76 people for Umrah trips and issuing fake receipts and airline tickets. On 5 November 2026, Arab News reported that the Federal Investigation Agency’s anti-human-trafficking circle in Karachi had arrested a man linked to a travel agency, saying he collected about Rs7 million from 49 people for Umrah visas, tickets and packages and “issued fake air tickets and hotel vouchers” instead. Investigators said they were still tracing the money and looking for more victims. All of these remain allegations.
How to spot it early: a PDF is not a ticket. Take the booking reference to the airline’s own website or office and look it up. If it does not appear, you have your answer while there is still time to act. Payment to a personal account is a warning in its own right, as both this case and the Pakistani ministry’s guidance make clear.
4. The hotel that was never arranged

Not every failure here is criminal fraud, but it can hurt just as much. In April 2026 Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Hajj and Umrah suspended three Umrah companies because “some pilgrims arrived in the Kingdom without the approved accommodation”. It ordered them to house those pilgrims immediately and said it was acting against the overseas agents as well. In October 2026, The National reported four more suspensions, this time for putting pilgrims in unlicensed housing. The ministry did not name the companies in the statement we read, so neither do we.
First Travel also shows how this can happen behind the scenes: Arab News reported it owed about Rp 24 billion to three hotels in Makkah and Madinah. A family’s account published in 2017, from a Hajj trip by British pilgrims, describes a promised family room turning into separated, crowded rooms with one bathroom for eight people.
How to spot it early: get the hotel’s exact name and your dates in writing, then contact the hotel directly and ask whether a reservation exists. Malaysia’s commercial crime chief gave the same advice in 2025, telling the public to check whether the company is registered with hotels in Makkah. For the Madinah leg, you can compare what you are promised against our Madinah hotel pages. Be precise about the distance as well. “Near the Haram” means little, so ask for the walking time and check it yourself on a map. More questions to ask are in the Umrah package checklist.
5. The return flight nobody paid for

This scam catches people after the worship is done. In April 2024, the Maldivian outlet Edition reported that a cheque for the tickets of 50 pilgrims had bounced, leaving them stranded in Saudi Arabia. The company reportedly told them on 16 April to buy their own tickets, then flew them back at its own cost four days later. The same report says the Ministry of Islamic Affairs had revoked a licence the year before, after a similar bounced cheque stranded 138 pilgrims in Makkah, and that the owner had then opened a new company with no licence. The ministry told the public not to pay that company or its affiliates.
How to spot it early: check the return leg on its own with the airline, not just the outward one. Ask for it again a week before you fly. Look at the name on your contract too, and check that exact legal name on the official list, since an operator’s old reputation may not belong to the company taking your money. Carry enough on a card to buy a flight home if you can. That is the difference between an expensive problem and a crisis.
6. Fake websites and copied logos

Officials in several countries keep repeating this warning. On 12 May 2026 Gulf News reported that Dubai Police’s Anti-Fraud Centre had warned of fake Hajj and Umrah campaigns using steep discounts, “guaranteed” bookings, urgent visas and advance payments, along with fake accounts and sites that copy the logos of known companies. It said activity rises in the weeks before the season.
Saudi officials said much the same in April 2023, when the ministry’s undersecretary said of a circulating registration link that it “certainly does not belong to the Ministry of Hajj and Umrah”. In Britain, Hyphen reported in March 2026 that City of London Police had logged 34 Hajj-related fraud reports in 2025 with £195,752 in losses, the largest single loss £64,000, and a “trickle” of reports about fake versions of Nusuk. Those UK figures are for Hajj rather than Umrah, and the Council of British Hajjis has estimated that as few as 3% of victims report. The same site tricks would work just as well on an Umrah buyer.
How to spot it early: never reach a booking site from an advert or a forwarded link. Type the address yourself. The Saudi ministry’s website has a free e-service called Inquire About Licensed Umrah Companies and Establishments, which we opened on 9 November 2026. It searches Saudi Umrah companies by permit number, so ask your agent which Saudi company holds your contract and what its permit number is, then look it up yourself. It does not list overseas agents. An older address for an agent search, reported by Gulf News in 2023, would not open for us. Pakistan’s religious affairs ministry publishes its own list of attested Umrah tour operators, which held 132 companies when we read it on 9 November 2026. Our guide to Umrah apps covers the official apps worth installing, and the Nusuk app is the one to learn first.
7. WhatsApp links about your Nusuk card or Rawdah slot

This one targets you while you are already in Madinah Munawwarah. On 29 April 2026, Indonesia’s state broadcaster RRI reported from Madinah that its Hajj officials were warning of messages claiming a problem with a pilgrim’s Nusuk card and asking them to click a link. “Do not trust and do not click any links they send,” said the head of its Hajj media centre. The warning was issued in the Hajj season, but nothing about the trick depends on the season.
Officials also addressed paid access to the Rawdah directly. “Access to Raudhah is free,” said the head of the Madinah working area. “If anyone offers services and asks for payment, report them immediately to officers.” Access runs on a barcode system, through collective permits for groups or the Nusuk app for individuals.
How to spot it early: open Nusuk from the app already on your phone and look at your permit there. If it is fine, the message is a lie. If your group holds your permit, ask your group leader in person. Read our first-time guide to Masjid an-Nabawi before you arrive, and our notes on ziyarah etiquette, so that a stranger’s offer of a shortcut stands out as wrong.
8. Umrah as a reward for buying into a business

Here the trip is the bait for something else. Free Malaysia Today reported in February 2025 that 31 people from five parts of Malaysia said they had lost over RM300,000 since 2023 to a man using a “Datuk” title. They said they were sold business packages costing RM4,490 to RM13,090, with promises of sponsored Umrah, help selling “health coffee” and a chance to buy homes. Representatives with religious titles reportedly gave it credibility. Some received coffee samples, others nothing, and one woman said the Umrah due by March 2024 never came. She went to the police, and a federal police director said reports would be looked into. These are the complainants’ claims.
How to spot it early: Umrah is a travel product. If you must buy stock, recruit others or pay a joining fee to earn it, you are looking at a sales scheme with a religious wrapper. A title such as ustaz or Datuk does not stand in for a licence. Respect the title and check the company anyway.
9. Free Umrah with a job at the end of it

This is the most dangerous item on the list, because the victim can lose far more than money. In October 2025, ProPakistani reported that Pakistan’s Federal Investigation Agency had arrested the alleged leader of a network accused of luring poor women from small towns with free Umrah trips and domestic jobs in Saudi Arabia, collecting “sponsorship fees”, and then forcing them to beg in public under supervision. The FIA said it was working with Saudi authorities and Interpol. In February 2025, Arab News reported that the agency had taken four women off a flight at Karachi on Umrah visas, saying initial findings pointed to forced labour. Both are allegations under investigation.
The FIA’s advice was to be careful of agents offering free Umrah or overseas jobs and to use official helplines. An Umrah visa is not a work visa, so an agent who says one can become the other is giving you a reason to walk away. The steps for a real application are set out in the Umrah visa guide for Pakistan.
How to spot it early: be suspicious when someone else pays your costs, holds your documents or arranges your stay without telling you where. If an older relative or a neighbour mentions such an offer, take it seriously and ask to see the paperwork.
10. Fake Zamzam

Pilgrims carry this water home as something precious, which is why fraud here feels so low. In May 2017, Al Bawaba, citing the Saudi Gazette, reported a Saudi crackdown: a factory in Buraidah closed after 6,500 fake bottles were found, about 200,000 bottles destroyed at a Makkah warehouse, 1,600 found in Hail, and more than 3,000 seized from a car park in Madinah bearing King Abdullah Zamzam Water Project stickers. These are the most recent Saudi figures we could open, so we cannot say how common it is today.
How to spot it early: that last detail matters, because an official-looking sticker proved nothing in that case. The Saudi Food and Drug Authority warned against buying from unauthorised shops, so ask whether a seller is authorised, and avoid roadside or car-park sales. Be most careful with Zamzam offered far from Makkah or sold back home, where you cannot trace where it came from. If you are buying gifts as well, our list of dates in Madinah explains how to buy well at markets such as the Central Dates Market.
Other traps worth knowing
- Hajj on an Umrah visa. The ministry said in April 2025 that only the designated Hajj visa permits Hajj and that adverts outside Nusuk are deceptive. Gulf News cited Saudi media reports of five arrests for promoting fake Hajj packages online. Anyone telling you to stay on after Umrah is putting you at legal risk.
- Unlicensed airport rides. This is a licensing warning, not a fraud case: we found no official report of a pilgrim being cheated this way. The Transport General Authority set a SAR 5,000 fine and vehicle impounding for people carrying passengers at airports without a licence, Gulf News reported in October 2024. Licensed companies offer electronic payment and trip tracking, which gives you a record. Our guide from the airport to Masjid an-Nabawi lists the options, and getting to Madinah covers the wider route.
- Cloned social media accounts. A reader’s letter in Dawn in January 2024 described impostors copying a pilgrim’s profile and asking friends for urgent money while the pilgrim was away. That is one writer’s account, not an official finding, but it costs nothing to phone a relative before sending money.
Six checks before you pay anyone
- Check the exact company name on your government’s list, and ask which licensed Saudi company will serve you, then check its permit number on the Saudi ministry’s e-service. Do this again just before the final payment, because status can change. In February 2026 the Saudi ministry temporarily suspended contracts with about 1,800 overseas agencies, Business Today reported.
- Pay a company account by bank transfer. Pakistan’s ministry says “The money should be paid into the company account through banks”, and to keep the receipt and agreement.
- Keep your documents. Pakistan’s July 2026 rules, as reported by Daily Pakistan, say complaints will only be heard against verified operators, so an unverified agent may leave you with no route to complain.
- Ask for the booking reference. Business Today reported in 2026 that visas are issued against a reference covering licensed hotels, ground transport and return flights. Ask to see yours, and look up the flights yourself.
- Do not be rushed. Urgency is in almost every warning above. A real operator can wait a day while you check. If your dates are flexible, our note on the best time to visit Madinah may also help you avoid peak pressure.
- Tell someone at home. Share your itinerary and references with a relative, and agree that they will call you before sending money.
If it has already happened to you
Move quickly and write everything down. Save the adverts, chats, receipts and contracts, since posts can vanish. Report to the police in your own country and to the ministry that licenses Umrah operators there. The Melaka group went to both the police and a consumer tribunal, which is a useful model. Call your bank straight away about any recent transfer. If you are in Saudi Arabia without a hotel or a flight home, contact your country’s mission, and tell the Saudi authorities. A notice from the Chinese missions in Saudi Arabia, dated 12 October 2026, lists 911 for police in Makkah, Madinah, Riyadh and the Eastern Province and 999 for other regions. Then report the site or account, even if you avoided it: UK police told Hyphen that early reports help them take sites down.
Please do not feel ashamed. These schemes are built on trust and devotion, and they work on careful people. Reporting may be what protects the next family.
Frequently asked questions
❓What are the most common umrah scams?
The documented cases mostly involve money taken for packages that do not depart, invalid tickets, unarranged hotels and unpaid return flights. Officials also keep warning about fake websites and WhatsApp links. We found no reliable worldwide count, so we cannot rank them by frequency.
❓How do I check whether an Umrah agent is genuine?
Check the exact legal name on your own government's list if it has one, and ask which licensed Saudi company holds your contract, then check its permit number on the Saudi ministry's e-service. Then verify the flights with the airline and the reservation with the hotel. A licence alone is not enough, since one Malaysian agency under police investigation was reported to be licensed.
❓Is it safe to pay an Umrah agent in cash?
Pakistan's ministry tells pilgrims to pay into the company's account through a bank and to keep the receipt and agreement. Avoid cash and personal accounts. In the Malaysian court case above, money went into personal accounts.
❓Do I have to pay for a Rawdah permit?
Indonesian Hajj officials in Madinah said in April 2026 that access is free and that anyone asking for payment should be reported. Use the Nusuk app, or your group's collective permit.
❓Can I get my money back after an umrah scam?
It is often hard. First Travel's victims were still unsure about compensation two years after the verdict. Report quickly to your bank and the police, and keep every document. Consumer tribunals, where they exist, may be another route, so ask a local lawyer or adviser.
❓Can an Umrah visa be turned into a job in Saudi Arabia?
Treat that promise as a warning sign. Pakistan's FIA has warned about agents offering free Umrah or overseas jobs, and it is investigating cases where women were allegedly forced to beg after arrival. Get work visa questions answered by official channels only.
How we checked this article: we opened each source named here: the Saudi Ministry of Hajj and Umrah, New Straits Times, Arab News, The Jakarta Post, Malay Mail, The Sun (Malaysia), Free Malaysia Today, Dawn, Edition (Maldives), RRI, Gulf News, MINA, Hyphen, The National, ProPakistani, Al Bawaba, Business Today and Daily Pakistan. The police numbers come from a notice by the Chinese missions in Saudi Arabia, read through Xinhua on 1 November 2026. On 9 November 2026 we reread the Saudi ministry’s suspension notice and opened its licensed-company e-service, counted Pakistan’s attested-operator list (132 records), read Arab News’s 5 November report on the Karachi arrest and the UK government’s travel advice page, and confirmed that the New Straits Times report still loads. The 2023 agent-search address would not open for us. Police cases are allegations unless we say a court ruled. We could not open the City of London Police release itself, so its figures come through Hyphen and Dawn. This article is general information, not legal advice, and we have not dealt with any of these operators. Last checked 9 November 2026.
Related reading
Umrah Package Checklist: What to Check Before You Pay
An Umrah package checklist to use with your agent: company listing, Nusuk hotel booking, room sharing, insurance, refund terms and safe payment.
Nusuk App Guide: Permits, Bookings and Rawdah Slots
Nusuk app guide: register as a visitor, book free Umrah and Rawdah permits, confirm your slot in time, use the Instant Track and fix common errors.
Top 10 Apps for Umrah Pilgrims in Makkah and Madinah
The top 10 apps for Umrah pilgrims: Nusuk for permits and Rawdah, HHR for trains, plus transport, translation, emergency and food apps.
How to Get to Madinah: Flights, Haramain Train & Road
Flights into MED, the Haramain High-Speed Railway, driving from Makkah or Jeddah, buses, visa basics and how to get around Madinah once you arrive.
#Nusuk #Umrah #Planning #Safety